Skip to main content

ASTM D4169-23 sets the gold standard for testing the durability and reliability of shipping containers and packages, offering a comprehensive method to simulate real-world conditions they might face during transport. This practice ensures that every package, regardless of its journey, has the highest chance of reaching its destination in perfect condition. It’s a testament to a business’s commitment to quality and reliability, providing a uniform method to navigate the complexities of distribution with confidence. By adopting ASTM D4169-23, companies align with global standards of excellence, ensuring their products remain safe and secure, from the warehouse to the end customer.

ASTM D4169-23 a standard practice for performance testing of shipping containers and systems

The ASTM D4169 standard is designed to rigorously evaluate the durability and resilience of packaging materials under the stresses of the shipping environment. This evaluation is critical for ensuring that packages can protect their contents from the moment they leave the warehouse until they reach the end consumer.

To achieve this, the standard simulates a variety of risks that packages commonly face during transportation:

  • Vibrations from transit vehicles
  • Impacts from handling
  • Drops during loading and unloading
  • Compression from stacking
  • Atmospheric pressure changes during air transport.

This standard categorizes transportation scenarios into distinct cycles, tailored according to the type of cargo and the transportation method. For each specific scenario, ASTM D4169 specifies tests that assess how well the packaging can withstand particular hazards. The outcome of these tests helps in determining the “assurance level,” a measure that reflects the likelihood of the packaging sustaining damage during transit. This measure aids businesses in making informed decisions about their packaging solutions, ensuring that they are sufficiently robust to protect the product, yet not overly designed in a way that unnecessarily increases costs.

In 2023, the ASTM D4169 standard underwent significant modifications, incorporating a range of new features designed to enhance its applicability and effectiveness in evaluating shipping containers and systems. These updates reflect the evolving needs of the industry and the latest insights into the risks associated with the transport and handling of goods.

DISCOVER ALL THE RELEVANT INFORMATION OF THE ASTM D4169

New ASTM D4169-23: Understanding the updated standard

Key Updates in Terminology and Conditioning

Section 3

The update to sub-section 3.2.7 introduces a new definition for small and lightweight packages. These are now specifically categorized as packages that weigh under 10 lbs (approximately 4.53 kgs) and have a volume of less than 2.0 cubic feet (0.056 cubic meters).

This clarification aims to standardize the classification of packages, facilitating more accurate and relevant testing protocols for these types of packages.

For example, consider a multinational e-commerce business specializing in high-end jewelry. Under the updated ASTM D4169-23 definition, their standard shipping package, weighing 5 lbs and measuring 1.5 cubic feet, now falls into the “Small and Lightweight Packages” category.

This classification helps the business ensure its packaging meets the specific testing standards for smaller, lighter items, potentially optimizing packaging materials and costs.

Significance and Use

Section 11

A notable addition to Section 11 includes a clarification in sub-section 11.2, advising that if the shipping unit’s construction type is unknown, the default should be Type 1 Factors. Furthermore, a new sub-section, 11.4.1, details typical shipping density (freight) factors, providing a range from 10 lb/ft³ to 30 lb/ft³, with a default recommended value of 12.0 lb/ft³ if the specific distribution system’s average shipping density factor is unknown.

For manufacturers accustomed to using specific box types without compression issues, a shipping density of 10 may still be justified. However, for those seeking a higher margin of safety, a shipping density of 12 is recommended. This adjustment could lead to an increase in the vehicle stacking top load required for a given package, enhancing its durability in the distribution environment.

Consider a scenario where the company is shipping a standard EV battery pack, sized 40″x24″x12″ and weighing 150 lbs. Under the ASTM D4169-22 standard, utilizing a shipping density factor of 10, the vehicle stacking requirement might have been set at 1,200 lbf for Assurance Level I. Transitioning to ASTM D4169-23, with a density factor update to 12, the revised guidelines would now require the packaging to withstand a top load of approximately 1,440 lbf for the same volume and weight.

Additionally, Section 11 introduces terms to aid users in selecting the appropriate Shipping Unit Construction and suggests that the safety factor “F” can be reduced by 30% for identical palletized shipping units, providing clearer guidelines for industry professionals.

For larger commercial EV battery units, let’s imagine a package dimension of 60″x36″x18″ weighing 300 pounds. Previously, such a package would need to support a vehicle stacking top load of roughly 2,500 lbf according to D4169-22 standards. With the new revision in D4169-23, adopting the higher shipping density factor translates to a necessity for the packaging to endure a top load of about 3,000 lbf, marking a significant increase in the required durability.

Section 12

In Section 12, particularly within Schedule D – Stacked Vibration, the update specifies an adjustment to the recommended shipping density factor (Mf) from 10 to 12 lb/ft³. This change is poised to impact how stacked vibration and compressive load tests are conducted, ensuring that the testing conditions more accurately reflect the challenges faced during shipping and handling.

Another example can be A wine distributor that uses custom-designed boxes for shipping premium bottles. According to the previous standard, the packaging was tested with a shipping density factor (Mf) of 10 lb/ft³. With ASTM D4169-23’s increase to 12 lb/ft³, the distributor must reassess the box’s design to ensure it can withstand higher compressive loads during stacked vibration tests, guaranteeing the bottles’ safety throughout the distribution process.

Another example can be A wine distributor that uses custom-designed boxes for shipping premium bottles. According to the previous standard, the packaging was tested with a shipping density factor (Mf) of 10 lb/ft³. With ASTM D4169-23’s increase to 12 lb/ft³, the distributor must reassess the box’s design to ensure it can withstand higher compressive loads during stacked vibration tests, guaranteeing the bottles’ safety throughout the distribution process.

The ASTM D4169-23 update reflects the ongoing efforts of ASTM International and industry experts to refine and enhance the standards governing the performance testing of shipping containers and systems. By introducing precise definitions and detailed testing criteria, the revised standard aims to better equip manufacturers, testers, and stakeholders across various industries to ensure the safety, integrity, and durability of packages throughout their distribution lifecycle.

Leave a Reply